________________ CM . . . . Volume V Number 16 . . . . April 9, 1999

cover The Racing Worm Brothers.

Gary Barwin. Illustrated by Kitty Macaulay.
Toronto, ON: Annick Press, 1998.
32 pp, cloth & paper, $15.95 (cl), $5.95 (pbk.).
ISBN 1-55037-541-5 (cl), ISBN 1-55037-540-7 (pbk).

Subject Headings:
Worms-Juvenile fiction.
Racing-Juvenile fiction.
Brothers-Juvenile fiction.

Kindergarten-grade 2 / Ages 5-7.
Review by Alison Mews.

*** /4


...Ryan suggested that they have a worm race. He drew a starting line near the swings.
The finish line was the stop sign at the very end of the street.
When the worms were ready, Ryan shouted, "Go!" and the worm race began.
They ran to the end of the street to wait for the worms.
Ryan said, "Pinky is the world's fastest worm. Your worm is slow as spaghetti."
"My worm is going to win," Aaron said. "GO, WORM!" he shouted.
They waited for a long time at the finish line, but the worms didn't come. They ran back along the racecourse, looking for their worms.
"Worms!" Aaron called. "Where are you?"
"Here, Pinky! Here, Worm!" Ryan called, but they couldn't find their worms anywhere.
inside picture Brothers Aaron and Ryan, who are unable to own traditional pets because of Aaron's allergies, adopt two backyard worms as pets. They sing to them, pat them and give them rides on swings and bicycles, but, when they release them for a race, the worms disappear. The boys, undaunted, assume Pinky and Worm are continuing to race underground. They draw a helpful map of the neighborhood, which they move each day, believing the worms consult it at night. There is no further sign of the worms all summer, yet the boys imagine the worms are making their way underground to the finish line. Their patience is rewarded on the first rainy day of school when, waiting to cross the street, they spy two worms at the stop sign. Deciding a winner cannot be determined, the boys cheerfully bring their 'pets' to school where they are met with a less than enthusiastic response from their teachers.

      That children imbue both animate and inanimate objects with human characteristics is undeniable and that two brothers, thwarted by allergies, would choose worms for pets is completely credible. That they would maintain the competition for a whole summer, despite the participation of the worms is, however, quite unlikely. Whether the worms found in September are the original worms is open to interpretation, as both times Barwin uses the same adjectives with an indefinite article, eg. "a short, fat worm. Regardless, the boys' anticipation is infectious, and Macaulay's illustrations engaging. Energetic and childlike, the pictures match the text and provide additional humour. Not only does she give the worms comical expressions, but also depicts a busy, underground anthropomorphic world.

      I should note a glaring mistake on the first page. The second line reads: "Any other pet would sneeze and break out in bumps because Aaron was allergic." This caused great amusement to the child with whom I shared the book, at the thought of Aaron causing animals to sneeze and break into hives! Because of the male protagonists and subject matter, this lighthearted story will undoubtedly appeal more to boys, or to any child who has indulged in backyard worm or (in my neighbourhood) snail races.


Alison Mews is the Coordinator of the Centre for Instructional Services in the Faculty of Education at Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, NF.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.

Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364