________________ CM . . . . Volume XX Number 5. . . .October 4, 2013


The Sinking of the Wiley Bean. (Babysitter Out of Control! Bk. 5).

Margaret J. McMaster. Illustrated by Manuel N. Cadag.
Kingsville, ON: Mansbridge Dunn Publishers, 2013.
50 pp., pbk., $12.95.
ISBN 978-0-9810525-5-7.

Grades 1-3 / Ages 6-8.

Review by Willow Moonbeam.

** /4



We trudged through the sand until the beach tapered off into the sea. Colonel Peabody rolled up his pants and waded into the water.

"Follow me!" he shouted as he scrambled over the rocks and disappeared around the spit of land.

I came up behind him and had my first glimpse of the cove. The sand sparkled like a million diamonds.

"Wow!" I said in awe.

"I don't think the tourists have found this place yet," he said.

It was the perfect spot to look for lucky stones and seashells. There weren't any empty pop cans or wrappers lying around.


The Sinking of the Wiley Bean is the fifth book in the “Babysitter Out of Control!” series by Margaret J. McMaster. Mrs. Chairbottom, the babysitter, is going to marry Colonel Peabody. They have travelled to the island of Mongo Tongo, taking Stewart with them, to plan the wedding before the other guests arrive. While Mrs. Chairbottom is attending to the details of the wedding, Stewart and Colonel Peabody go beachcombing, and they find a figurehead buried in the sand. This is when the mystery begins and when everything starts to go wrong.

internal art     The story is written from the viewpoint of the boy, Stewart. He is the one who takes actions, witnesses the actions that the others take, and has the dreams that contain clues to what is happening. There are really two stories here: that of the wedding and the mystery surrounding the figurehead that Stewart found on the beach. The two are ingeniously linked in several ways, and both are resolved at the end of the story.

     The illustrations by Manuel N. Cadag are textured, like comic book pages. The characters are completely recognizable and consistent with the illustrations from the previous book in the series, What Happened in July. Each illustration is perfectly connected to the story and placed well.

     As previously noted, in The Sinking of the Wiley Bean, Stewart also solves the mystery and participates in each step of the action. This is more rewarding than in the previous book where Stewart was present for the solution of the mystery but did not take the actions himself. The clues are interestingly laid out. Using dream sequences as part of the trail is inventive and successful, and the clues are easy to identify within the story. Overall, the plot is too complex to be completely satisfying, and with all the people mentioned, often briefly, it is difficult to keep track of who they are. This problem would be minimized if readers were familiar with all of the previous books in the series.

      Margaret J. McMaster uses a pleasing, fast writing style completely appropriate for an early chapter book. Anyone who has enjoyed the “Babysitter Out of Control!” books up to this point will delight in this latest addition to the series.


Willow Moonbeam is a librarian and college math professor living in Toronto, ON, with an interest in knitting, astrology and learning new things.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.