CM . . .
. Volume XX Number 15. . . .December 13, 2013
Peter Unwin is a talented storyteller with a dry sense of humour who makes history interesting. In this collection consisting of 20 chapters, he introduces historical figures who were active in many fields of endeavour including literature (John Richardson, Pauline Johnson, and the poet of cheese James McIntyre), visual art (Paul Kane and Robert Markle), business (J.R. Booth), conservation (Jack Miner and Grey Owl) and sport (Tom Longboat, and the history of lacrosse). In addition to biographical essays, he includes a few essays on topics such as the history of duelling in Canada, the history of trees, the death of Jumbo the elephant in St. Thomas, ON, and the sinking of the Mayflower in 1912. To his credit, Unwin avoids hagiography; he relishes controversy and helps to burst the myths that surround some of the subjects. This is very obvious in the essay on Jack Miner who is regarded as a leading conservationist yet whose actions often contradict such a label. Similarly, Grey Owl, born Archibald Furmage (later Belaney) who portrayed himself as a Native North American and conservationist is also shown to have led a somewhat un-admirable life, especially with regards to his relations with women. In balance, Unwin highlights Grey Owl’s accomplishments as a writer, lecturer and conservationist.
The excerpt above from a biography of Paul Kane illustrates Unwin’s desire to expose as racist attitudes and opinions expressed by the subject and his contemporaries. He is unafraid of making his own biases clear, as in his critical tone surrounding J.R. Booth’s lumbering empire that saw the decimation of the virgin pine forests of Ontario during one man’s lifetime. Even in this account, Unwin demonstrates the humanity of his subject. Unfortunately, he does not include any formal footnotes, endnotes or sources for further reading. This will frustrate readers wanting to explore the topics more fully. Perhaps one reason for not doing this was to hide the fact that many of the chapters have previously been published in a different form in the popular historical magazine The Beaver (now called Canada’s History). The magazine versions typically include bibliographical notes and relevant images that are also absent from the present work.
There are a number of factual errors that this reader noted that should have been caught by good fact-checking editors. Unwin identifies John Richardson’s novel Ecarté, published in 1829, as being likely the first novel published by a Canadian-born author. In fact, it is Julia C.B. Hart’s St. Ursula’s Convent, or, The Nun of Canada, published in Kingston, Upper Canada, in 1824 that is regarded as the first Canadian novel. He refers to a Paul Kane painting at the Art Gallery of Ontario by the title Indian Encampment at Georgian Bay. The AGO’s website gives this work the title Indian Encampment on Lake Huron. More obvious errors are his statement that the sinking of the Mayflower on Lake Kamaniskeg in Ontario that claimed nine lives “remains the largest inland marine disaster in Canadian history.” The loss of the Edmund Fitzgerald on Lake Superior in 1975 claimed 29 lives. Another glaring error is the reference to Leslie Frost, who wrote a preface to Selwyn Dewdney’s Indian Rock Paintings of the Great Lakes as the prime minister of Canada. In fact, Frost was the premier or first minister of Ontario from 1949-1961 and certainly not a head of state. Dewdney’s book identifies Frost correctly.
Canadian Folk is currently being marketed by the Toronto Star alongside other works of popular Canadian and local history. It is most suited to recreational readers interested in short biographies of some of the colourful Canadians of the past. The publisher emphasizes the quirky content with its “fresh look at the saints, sinners, oddballs, and outright nutbars who have populated the Canadian landscape.”
Despite the entertaining read that most of the chapters allow, the abundant errors of fact and lack of scholarly features earn this work at best a recommendation with reservations. The book is most suited to public libraries.
Recommended with reservations.
Val Ken Lem is the liaison librarian for History, English and Caribbean Studies at Ryerson University in Toronto, ON.
on this title or this review, send mail to email@example.com.
Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal
use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any
other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.