________________ CM . . . . Volume XX Number 14. . . .December 6, 2013


“When Did You See Her Last?” (All the Wrong Questions, 2).

Lemony Snicket. Art by Steh.
Toronto, ON: HarperCollins, 2013.
277 pp., hardcover, $16.99.
ISBN 978-1-44340-195-1.

Grades 4-9 / Ages 9-14.

Review by Jocelyn Reekie.

***½ /4



“Dr. Flammarion has been serving as their private apothecary for a few weeks now.”

“What does that mean?” I asked.

“Flammarion is a tall pink bird,” Theodora said.

“An apothecary,” continued the woman more helpfully, “is something like a doctor and something like a pharmacist. For years Dr. Flammarion worked at the Colophon Clinic, just outside town, before coming here to treat the Knights. He’s been using a special medicine, but they just keep getting worse.”

“That must have been very upsetting for Miss Knight,” I said.

Zada and Zora looked very sad. “It made Miss Knight very lonely,” one of them said. “It is a lonely feeling when someone you care about becomes a stranger.”

“So Miss Knight has no one caring for her,” Theodora said thoughtfully. …

…She was also wrong about no one caring for Miss Knight. Zada and Zora were the ones who were beside themselves with worry. I leaned forward and looked first at Zada and then at Zora, or perhaps the other way around. And then, while my chaperone licked her fingers, I asked the question that is printed on the cover of this book.

It was the wrong question, both when I asked it and later, when I asked the question to a man wrapped in bandages. The right question in this case was “Why was she wearing an article of clothing she did not own?” but this is not an account of times when I asked the right questions, much as I wish it were.


In volume two of Daniel Handler’s Lemony Snicket’s “All the Wrong Questions” series, our 13-year-old apprentice detective is faced with solving the mystery of another disappearance while he continues to search for answers to several mysteries introduced in Who Could That Be at This Hour?, the series’ opening volume: a girl named Ellington Feint, her kidnapped father, the statue of the Bombinating Beast and a villain named Hangfire all remain parts of the jigsaw puzzle—each of us parts of the same big picture—that had brought Lemony Snicket and his chaperone, S. Theordora Markson, to the town of Stain’d-by-the-Sea in the first place.

internal art     New to the picture is a brilliant young scientist named Miss Cleo Knight. Miss Knight is the only child of parents who inherited Ink Inc. from Cleo’s grandmother, Ingrid Nummet Knight, who had discovered how to make the darkest ink, taken from octopi, which industry turned Stain’d-by-the-Sea into a thriving town and the Knights into its wealthiest citizens. Now, however, the octupi are on the verge of extinction, the town is dying, and Miss Knight, who inherited her grandmother’s brilliant scientific mind, has been working to develop an invisible ink that will revive the industry and put the town back on the map. But Miss Knight has gone missing, and Dr. Flammarion is injecting her parents regularly with a drug he says is called Beekabackabooka, but it is really Laudanum, a substance that induces an almost coma-like state in its recipients. All in all, a nasty situation that leads Lemony into ever more dangerous circumstances as he strives to find answers to difficult questions.

     And once again, the adults in the town, in this case: Polly Partial—owner of Partial Foods; Mr. Bellerophon, owner of the town’s only taxi service; Mr. and Mrs. Knight; Harvey and Mimi Mitchum, the town police; Prosper Lost—owner of the Lost Arms, where Lemony and his chaperone are staying; Zada and Zora, twins who are servants to the Knights; Colonel Colophon, Ingrid Nummet Knight’s old business partner; and retired newspaper man, Mr. Mallhan, are of no help at all, while other adults, Dr. Flammarion; his nurse, Nurse Dander, who is good with a knife; S. Theodora Markson, and the infamous Hangfire, more than hinder Lemony’s success.

     Fortunately, girl-journalist Moxie Mallahan and the Bellerophon brothers, Pip and Squeak, are still around to help; Ellington Feint resurfaces, and Lemony comes across Jake Hix, a young dishwasher-cook who not only serves up delicious food free of charge, likes the same books Snicket likes, but is also more than simply acquainted with Cleo Knight—a fact that proves vital down the road. Thus the army of children fighting for right expands, much in the sense of King Arthur’s Knights of the Round Table.

     At the same time, a mystery that is developing far away in the city, in which Lemony’s sister, Kit, is the main character, deepens when she is discovered trying to break into a museum to retrieve…something apparently important. Perhaps we’ll find out in volume three what that item is. The crux of that story in this volume is that Kit is discovered and now faces being sent to prison, a fact that causes Lemony great sadness and concern. The only thing Lemony has to hang onto with regard to his sister’s dilemma, and the state of the world he’s found himself in, is a saying he and his child-apprentice colleagues learned from one of their associates: “No reality has the power to dispel a dream,” which here means that no matter what happens in the world, you can keep thinking about something, particularly if it’s something you like.

     The saying will resonate with many, but overall, readers may find When Did You See Her Last? has a more sinister, less hopeful feel to it than did volume one of Handler’s series. While the power of children to think out of the box and come up with creative solutions to problems is mighty, a world in which no adult ever takes care of or is able to help the children in their custody, and many adults are downright threats to the children’s welfare, is a very sad world. Some readers may also find the many references thrown in regarding books Lemony has read weighty enough to be annoying as the references don’t seem to have any real connection to the mysteries or the solving of them and, therefore, feel gratuitous.

     That said, this second volume of the series contains the same kind of clever twists and turns and the same wit that made Who Could That Be at This Hour? an exciting read. And readers will find themselves drawn ever deeper into the stories of the compelling characters.

     Likewise, Seth’s intricate illustrations are once again clever and informative, and heighten readers’ interest in both the characters and the landscape.

     So, on goes Handler’s “first authorized autobiographical account of Lemony Snicket’s childhood”, and this reader is already anxious to read volume 3.

Highly Recommended.

Jocelyn Reekie is a writer, editor and publisher in Campbell River, BC.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.