________________ CM . . . . Volume XIX Number 41. . . .June 21, 2013


The Birchy Maid.

Robin McGrath. Illustrated by Rochelle Baker.
St. John's, NL: Tuckamore Books/Creative Book Publishing, 2013.
25 pp., hardcover, $19.95.
ISBN 978-1-77103-008-3.

Preschool-grade 4 / Ages 4-9.

Review by Amber Allen.

*** /4



Then he asked his third daughter, the youngest of the three, how much she loved him, and the girl looked at him sadly and said she loved him as much as soup loves salt. But there was no way to measure this answer, so the old man closed his ledger in anger and led his child to the door of his house and turned her out. She stood on the stoop for a moment, thinking what she might do and then without looking back, she marched quickly down the path, past the stores and flakes, and into the woods, not once looking up to see if her father was watching her from the windows of the high room.


The Birchy Maid is a fairy tale for modern sensibilities. It tells the tale of the youngest daughter of an unhappy merchant. Asked to quantify her love for her father's ledger of wealth, she expresses it in a way that is immeasurable. Displeased with her answer, her father turns her out, and she is forced to fend for herself in the forest surrounding her family's land. When she comes across a handsome house, from which is wafting the smell of fresh baking bread, she comes up with a plan to gain entry to satiate her hunger. Covering her beautiful clothes with the bark of a birch tree, she asks to work in the kitchen in return for food, and she is admitted. During a dance in honour of the son of the house, which the Birchy Maid attends sans her disguise, the son falls in love with her, and, when refused her hand in marriage, he takes to his bed. It takes the Birchy Maid's soup to bring him back from his depression, and they get married on one very specific condition: she must serve her soup at the reception.

internal art

     The classic fairy tale style of The Birchy Maid is parenthetically framed by an allusion to a young girl who is hearing the tale told at school. To my mind, these first and last pages were superfluous and jarring. That being said, the tale, itself, was whimsical and entertaining. The heroine is cunning, but she has a grace and kindness to her which is entirely endearing. We, as readers, become empathetically involved in her story. The tone and flow are perfectly suited to the style. The Birchy Maid is a highly engaging story with the ideal instance of comeuppance in the end.

      The illustrations are full of bright, saturated colours and complement the classic feel of the text. Especially charming are the ornately designed first letters on each page, at once unique and traditional. The pictures depict the most important moments in the story well, but they do not add anything extra to the experience of their own merit.

     Overall, The Birchy Maid is a wonderful example of the continuing importance and appeal of the fairy tale. Her self-reliance makes her a great role model for children, and the writing is easily accessible. Still, it would have behooved the book to have left the surrounding context (the school children hearing the story) out and to focus the full energy on the tale itself.


Amber Allen is a librarian in Toronto, ON, with a passion for children's literature.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.