________________ CM . . . . Volume XVI Number 24. . . .February 26, 2010

cover

The Great Motion Mission: A Surprising Story of Physics in Everyday Life.

Cora Lee. Illustrated by Steve Rolston.
Toronto, ON: Annick Press, 2009.
114 pp., pbk. & hc., $14.95 (pbk.), $24.95 (hc.).
ISBN 978-1-55451-184-6 (pbk.),
ISBN 978-1-55451-185-3 (hc.).

Subject Heading:
Physics-Juvenile literature.

Grades 6-11 / Ages 11-16.

Review by Katarin MacLeod.

**1/2/4

   

excerpt:

Art galleries aren't exactly high on my list of favorite places to visit.

"Yes, I need to take photos of their latest acquisition,"said Liam.

"Whoopee," I said. I didn't move.

"Oh come on, one of the exhibits is on comics and cartoons. Not what I'd call art, but you might like it,"Said Liam. "And you might find some kids to talk to."

I got the hint, and Audrey and I followed Liam to the elevator, where he punched the up button. We got out two levels up, and Liam let us down a softly lit hallway. Frowning at Audrey, he said, "Maybe you'll learn something here, too - about a smart bunch of people who don't need physics. Artists and physicists are like different species, see. "He swept his arm out over the paintings lining the walls." All this? Made from 100-percent pure, creative juices. It's as far as you get from dread technical physics. At completely opposite ends of the spectrum.

"Audrey pounced on that last word. "A spectrum - the electromagnetic spectrum - is exactly what they have in common!"

The Great Motion Mission is a fictional story about Jeremy, a boy who might be in grade 9 or 10 and who is ready for summer vacation. However, this particular summer will be like no other. His best friend, Sam, who lives next door, is off to math camp all summer, and Jeremy is not interested in wasting his summer learning math. Sam's parents have an exchange student staying with them while Sam is away. Her name is Audrey, and, although she looks like a typical girl, she has a passion for physics and sees physics as being just about everything. Jeremy has been instructed to include Audrey in his summer plans so that she does not feel like an outsider. Finally, there is Uncle Liam, Jeremy's uncle, who lives in Jeremy's basement. He is a newspaper reporter who is very opinionated.

     Uncle Liam has been told by the newspaper to report on a conference being held at the local university, the XIV Symposium on the Universality of Physics. This conference is to replace the annual summer fair held in the community, but Uncle Liam has a "phobia when it comes to physics" and is going to try and do everything possible to cancel the conference with Jeremy's help. Jeremy finds himself caught as a double-agent - attempting to assist Uncle Liam with cancelling the conference and then being encouraged by Audrey to help foil Liam's plan so that the conference can go ahead.

     During the time leading up to the conference, Jeremy, Audrey, Uncle Liam and other friends play sports, visit an art gallery, speak with a musician and discuss fair rides. Each of these "non physics' appearing activities is decoded by Audrey as applications of various real-world occurrences of physics laws and principles.

     In the end, the conference was a huge success - for physicists that attended, school age children, and those who had little background in physics. Jeremy learned a lot about how physics impacts his life and the world around him in many different ways. He also learned that he may not understand everything that a physicist says, but it is sure nice when you can understand bits and parts.

     The plot of The Great Motion Mission is interesting from a science education point of view, but young readers may become disinterested in the story as every chapter seems to follow a similar format, i.e., the characters embark on an activity or adventure; there is an assumption that no physics is taking place; and then Audrey gives the explanation of the occurrence as it pertains to the laws and concepts of physics. At no time is Audrey truly challenged or does Jeremy "figure it out on his own."

     The physics concepts and application of real world physics to the various scenarios are true, accurate and age appropriate. The illustrations and color coding of the key terms are also outstanding. This color coding is also present in the glossary which most students should find useful. The 'further reading' section is also very reasonable and useful for the adolescents whose interest has been sparked by physics and its application to the real world.

     Although this text could be read by a young reader for 'fun,' I also think that certain elements of the text could be assigned as supplemental reading material for high school physics curricula as the contents of the text are common to various provincial physics curricula. Alternatively, the physics or science teacher could read a section of the text to students that would pertain to the topic being studied to intrigue student interest and open up a discussion concerning the content and context. Finally, the text could be used as an exemplar for a culminating activity in the area of physics, i.e., students could use the model of the text to then explain everyday phenomena in both physics and plain language terms to a younger audience.

Recommended.

Katarin MacLeod is an Assistant Professor in Science Education at St. Francis Xavier University in Antigonish, NS. Her areas of interest include physics educational research (PER), and the incorporation of science, technology, society and environment (STSE) outcomes into science courses at all levels to help students understand the relevancy of science, increase scientific literacy, and to promote citizenship.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.
 

NEXT REVIEW | TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR THIS ISSUE - February 26, 2010.

AUTHORS | TITLES | MEDIA REVIEWS | PROFILES | BACK ISSUES | SEARCH | CMARCHIVE | HOME