CM . . .
. Volume XVI Number 22. . . .February 12, 2010
Animals' Day is set on the Island located just south of Toronto and a popular place for tourists and Torontonians to spend a summer day. The Island also has a residential area which contains two hundred and fifty cottages. Apart from being a home to "nearly one thousand, including pets," the Island harbors many wild animals.
In Klunder's text, once a year the animals living on the Island dress up like people and do all the things that humans do when they relax, such as playing musical instruments, bathing, cycling, boating and napping. This alliterative alphabet book sets about documenting their fun and games in 26 sets of pages, one for each letter of the alphabet, with the text facing a related illustration.
Barbara Klunder is an illustrator who is gifted in a variety of art genres. She has spent most of her time in the past twenty years on the Toronto Island and is a teacher of drawing and painting at the Art Gallery of Ontario. She is committed to environmental issues, and her previous book, Other Goose: Recycled Rhymes for Our Fragile Times, reflects this interest.
Despite these sterling qualities, it is doubtful if the format and rather awkward alliterative text will appeal to young children. And while picture books for older readers are an increasingly popular genre, they usually deal with more complex themes than the subject matter of this volume.
There are elements of the text that jar on readers of any age. The storyline is self-conscious and stilted, and the interjection of the author's environmental observations e.g. "unwanted Island airport", "gas guzzling cars" and coy references to obviously known Island residents, such as the "Island's quality quilter" and the "hip hairdresser," are inappropriate in this context.
As the book stands, I feel it is more suitable for older children aged between 8-11. I would recommend it for purchase in libraries in the Greater Toronto Area and as an additional purchase in other school and public libraries.
Recommended with reservations.
Aileen Wortley, a retired librarian, lives in Toronto, ON.
on this title or this review, send mail to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal
use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any
other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.