________________ CM . . . . Volume XV Number 11 . . . . January 23, 2009

cover A Walk Through a Window.

K.C. Dyer.
Toronto, ON: Doubleday Canada, 2009.
230 pp., pbk., $12.95.
ISBN 978-0-385-66637-4.

Grades 4-6 / Ages 9-11.

Review by Joan Marshall.

*** /4

Reviewed from Advance Reading Copy.


"Ah — I knew ye for an idiot the first time I laid eyes on ye," The captain growled. "Ye picked the wrong vessel to sneak aboard, and ye'll earn yer passage like the rest." Alec grabbed Gabriel firmly by one ear. And in case that wasn't enough, he twisted Gabe's arm behind his back until he winced and then frog-marched him to the door.

The door slammed behind them so hard that it bounced open and didn't latch. Darby sank back down onto the floor and tried to gather her thoughts.


Here she was again. Or more to the point — here she wasn't. She wasn't at home anymore. She wasn't in her own time and she wasn't even sure she was in her right mind.


She also wasn't scared. Not really. For one thing, there was very little chance that a polar bear would be chasing her any time soon. Just the thought of it brought a quiet laugh to her lips.

Darby had handled a lot this summer. She's been yarded out of her regular life, dumped by her parents with a crazy grandfather and found out that not everything she'd grown to believe was really what it seemed. The polar bear was the clincher, though.

She still didn't know if that thing had really been chasing her or if it was just a phantom product of one killer of a headache. But if Gabe wanted her to have an open mind, he could rest assured now — her mind was open. She was desperate to find out more.

It made her feel better that she was not alone. Gabe might not be right at her side, but at least she knew roughly where he could be found: on deck, mending sails under Alec's watchful eye, no doubt.

He had risked another smack on the head to tell Darby to get out of this strange little room, have a look around and learn something.

So that's what she did.

Thirteen-year-old Darby is spending the summer with her grandparents in Charlottetown, (lovingly described here, complete with colourful gingerbread houses), while her parents renovate their Toronto home. Gabe, a mysterious boy who speaks quite formally, invites Darby through a window as a storm hits, and she finds herself in an Inuit campsite of pre-history Canada as the family finds the caribou herd that will sustain their lives for another season. Gabe also draws her back in time to an Irish immigrant coffin ship and to a Scottish ship docking in Charlottetown in 1875. On both of these ships, Darby sees members of her own family — her grandfather's great grandfather and her grandmother's great grandmother. Gabe's visions of the past help Darby to understand her family and their precarious and tragic background. Shawnie, a neighbour of her grandparents and an Inuit from Rankin Inlet, is the third piece of the puzzle, with the Scots and the Irish, that comprises the history of PEI. Shawnie constructs an inuksuk with the rocks that Darby has brought back from her time travels. Over the summer Darby grows to love her grandparents as she helps Nan to keep track of Gramps, who is gradually slipping into Alzheimer's disease. Darby's visions/timeslips are explained as migraines. When Gramps dies of a heart attack, Darby's parents fly in for the funeral and to pick her up, and Darby promises to visit Nan again next summer.

     Darby is a great character — initially too cool and cynical about the slow pace of provincial Charlottetown, she is determined to master her new skateboard and is embarrassed by her weird grandparents. As she gains understanding through sad and horrific visions of history, Darby matures enough to understand her grandmother's strength and begins to help her deal with Gramps. In the end, Darby can even graciously accept that her own mother is pregnant.

     Gabe, the time traveller, who appears as a different character is each timeslip, is kind, generous and insistent that Darby merely listen, watch and learn. Although he appears ghost-like, perhaps it is his Acadian French family that is returning to Charlottetown from New Orleans to renovate Gramp's family's old ramshackle home.

     Nan and Gramps are authentic characters, late seventies in age, firm, yet loving in their approach to Darby. Gramp's Alzheimer's is thoughtfully portrayed, complete with the odd "goddamn", as is Nan's determination to keep him at home as long as she can. Less clear is why Darby's parents haven't clued her in on Gramp's illness or on the arrival of a sibling, which seems unrealistic.

     The other odd glitch in this novel is the seeming importance of the summer journal, which just peters out to nothing. Darby doesn't keep track of her summer activities. Rather, she does research about her family's history at the local library.

     Gabe and the device of the window in the crumbling building in the backyard of Gramp's family's old house are believable. Vivid descriptions of the past, complete with authentic language and behaviour, will intrigue the intended reader.

     Both boys and girls in late elementary school will enjoy this timeslip fantasy built on the history of Canada's people and past.


Joan Marshall is a Winnipeg, MB, bookseller.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.

Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.