________________ CM . . . . Volume XII Number 16 . . . .April 14, 2006


The Star Supper: Book Three. (Our Canadian Girl).

Troon Harrison. Illustrated by Janet Wilson.
Toronto, ON: Penguin, 2006.
93 pp., pbk., $8.99.
ISBN 0-14-305006-0.

Subject Heading:
World War, 1914-1918-Ontario-Toronto-Juvenile fiction.

Grades 3-6 / Ages 8-11.

Review by Harriet Zaidman.

**½ /4

Reviewed from uncorrected and unpublished proofs.



"No tree? No log?" something plummeted into the pit of my stomach and settled with a cold, heavy weight. "Mother, it won't be Christmas without a tree! It's bad enough that Father isn't here!"

Hot tears spilled from my eyes when I mentioned Father. Mother pulled me close in a hug, but I squirmed away. I was being babyish, I knew, but I couldn't seem to move the weight in my stomach that pushed out my tears. Mother handed me a hanky and I blew my nose.


The world has turned upside down for Millie MacCallum, a young girl of middle class background who lives in Toronto just before and during World War I. In the first book, The Button Necklace, she exasperates her mother who expects Millie to act "like a lady." War has broken out in Europe, and Millie's father enlists to help out the British side, but he assures his daughter that the war will be over soon. In Book 2, Millie spends the summer with First Nations relatives in the Kawartha lakes region in Ontario where she thrives.

     Now back in the city, life is a struggle for everyone. Finances are tight. Millie's mother must hold a job as well as care for Millie and Millie’s baby sister, Louisa May. Mother becomes sick just before Christmas and is bedridden with a dangerous virus, and the servants have now gone off to war. A cook remains, but she must also care for her own aged mother, and so Millie is on her own for much of the time.

     Millie goes with the mother of her school friend, Edwina Sinclair, to find information about why people of Ukrainian and other Austrian-Hungarian heritage are being imprisoned and sent to work camps. Mrs. Sinclair is a crusading journalist who is incensed that ordinary working people who were enticed to come to Canada are now being branded as enemies because of their country of origin. A man slips Millie a note with strange looking letters and asks her to deliver it to his family.

     From then on, it's a race against time for Millie who comes home to find her aboriginal relations from up north on the doorstep. When she next opens the door, in walks Molly, a poor British waif Molly met in Book One in the part of town called The Ward. Molly's foster family arrangement has fallen apart, and she needs a place to stay. As the house fills up, Molly feeds them all and cares for her sister and sick mother. She delivers the letter, only to find the Petrenko family in need of food and friends. Added to that are Millie's own hopes that everything will be the same as it always has at Christmas time.

     So much happens in the space of 90 pages that the reader is left wondering how Millie can get some sleep, never mind cope with the demands placed on her.

     The plot deals with the incarceration of so-called enemy aliens, the poverty of European immigrants, the clash of cultures and resulting racism, the concern about relatives fighting overseas, the threat of death from the most minor illness, the economic difficulties created by the war, and more. Millie is definitely a stalwart soul who figures out how to get everyone to help, but the plot is too complicated for this little girl to handle with such aplomb.

     Finally, Millie discovers that Christmas can be wonderful even if it is different from what she is used to. Young readers will learn a great deal about the different events and forces operating within society at the time by reading this book and the entire series.


Harriet Zaidman is a teacher-librarian in Winnipeg, MB.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.