________________ CM . . . . Volume XI Number 15. . . . April 1, 2005


Letters to the Editor


Fitzhenry & Whiteside
195 Allstate Parkway
Markham, Ontario
l3R 4T8

March 28, 2005

David Jenkinson, Editor
CM Magazine

Dear Mr. Jenkinson:

I am enclosing a copy of a letter recently received from Melanie Jane Banner, which in the interests of fairness, I am hoping you might run in an upcoming issue of CM. Having read and re-read Jane Bridle's review of Ms. Banner's first novel, Smoke, I find myself in agreement with the author's dismissal of the review as ill-informed and needlessly pedantic. Like the author, I too would hope that young readers will continue to tell other young readers what a marvelous adventure story it is.

Yours truly,

Sharon Fitzhenry

Rebuttal from Melanie Jane Banner to Jane Bridle's review of Smoke, CM Volume XI, Number 7

I am saddened, but also bemused by Jane Bridle's pedantic dismissal of my novel, Smoke. She seems to have completely misunderstood the story and I find her criticisms most unfair.

Smoke is not a Natural History book on The Wolf, but a fictional novel of a troubled boy's rite of passage into adulthood, encompassing loneliness, bullying, the breakdown of today's family, homelessness, and ultimately, true friendship and responsibility. The wild animal welfare issue is of course an important integral part too.

Ms Bridle's annihilation of Smoke seems vaguely based on a few debatable aspects of wolf behaviour. I researched the feasibility of this storyline extensively. I talked with specialists, rescue centres, wolf enthusiasts; and of course experts from The Born Free Foundation were very happy with the tale. A UK wild animal sanctuary uses some of its rescue wolves for educational purposes taking them along to schools, and even onto children's programmes on TV. They tell me some of their socialized wolves have much better temperaments than dogs. And often go inside the house, with children.

I do hope young readers will now flock to buy a copy of Smoke and make up their own minds. I think it would be very sad indeed to rob Canadian children of the joy of a story which has repeatedly been referred to as "the best animal story I have ever read" by children and adults alike in many countries of the world.

Melanie Jane Banner

  See the original review at Vol. XI, No. 7, November 26, 2004.


To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.