News Release: Thick Arctic Sea Ice Goes Missing

November 27th, 2009 · 7 Comments · Environment and Geography, News Release, Research

Arctic sea ice has duped satellites into reporting thick multiyear sea ice where in fact none exists, a new study by University of Manitoba researcher David Barber has found.

In 2008 and 2009 satellite data showed a growth in Arctic sea ice extension leaving some to reckon global warming was reversing. But after sailing an ice breaker to the southern Beaufort Sea this past September Dr. Barber and his colleagues found something unexpected: thin, “rotten” ice can electromagnetically masquerade as thick, multiyear sea ice. And contrary to what satellites recently suggested, we are actually speeding up the loss of the remaining, healthy, multiyear sea ice.

You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

The results of the study have now been accepted for publication in the peer reviewed journal Geophysical Research Letters, of the American Geophysical Union.

“These are very significant findings since the scientists and public all thought that sea ice was recovering since the minimum extent in 2007,” says Barber, a professor of Environment and Geography and Canada Research Chair in Arctic System Science.

In September 2009 Barber and others went to various points in the southern Beaufort Sea aboard the research vessel (NGCC) Amundsen. They discovered the multiyear sea icescape was not as ubiquitous as it appeared in satellite remote sensing data. And much of the multiyear ice, which is integral to maintaining the ecosystem and its inhabitants, was so heavily decayed the Amundsen easily broke through floes six to eight meters thick. Indeed, through most of the journey the Amundsen sailed at an average speed of 24km/h; its open water cruising speed is about 25km/h.

“Ship navigation across the pole is imminent as the type of ice which resides there is no longer a barrier to ships in the late summer and fall,” Barber says.

So why have satellites been fooled? When studying sea ice, satellites shoot microwaves at the icescape and, among other things, record how they scatter. Each variety of ice was thought to have its own unique scattering characteristics which researchers could read to determine where certain species of ice reside. But Barber and his colleagues discovered that multiyear ice and the “rotten” ice have similar near-surface temperatures, similar near-surface salinities, and both have similar open water and new sea ice fractions at the surface. So when satellites try to identify who’s who, the microwaves behave similar enough that cases of mistaken identity abound.

“Our results are consistent with ice age estimates that show the amount of multiyear sea ice in the northern hemisphere was the lowest on record in 2009 suggesting that multiyear sea ice continues to diminish rapidly in the Canada Basin even though 2009 aerial extent increased over that of 2007 and 2009,” the paper concludes.

“This has significant implications for assessment of the speed of global climate change impacts in the Arctic and for increased shipping and industrial development in the Arctic,” says Barber.
For media interested in using video of Dr. Barber talking about his study and footage taken from the Arctic right click and save the following:

For more information contact David Barber, Centre for Earth Observation Science, University of Manitoba, 204-474-6981 (

Or Sean Moore, public affairs, University of Manitoba, 204-474-7963 (

**Please note Dr. Barber will only be available for interviews on Friday, November 27, as he is again travelling to the Arctic on Monday.**

Tags: ·········

7 responses so far ↓

  • 1 conrad ziehlke // Nov 27, 2009 at 12:51 pm

    dr barber your presentation was well received at the amm convention.However sceptics abound. good luck with your work. It is ingods hands

  • 2 2009 set to become the Fifth hottest year on Record ( « Desertification // Dec 9, 2009 at 1:55 am

    […] University of Manitoba News Release, Nov 27, 2009 – News Release: Thick Arctic Sea Ice Goes Missing […]

  • 3 Andy // Dec 14, 2009 at 12:08 pm

    Dr Barber, most interesting….i was wondering if you could enlighten your readers as to how much ice cover existed in the Medieval Warm Period?….also what fraction of that ice was satellite duping ‘rotten ice’? Also can you reflect on ice cover at the south pole?

  • 4 “rotten” sea ice – not even in Denmark « Watts Up With That? // Dec 14, 2009 at 12:17 pm

    […] the satellites had identified as thick, multiyear ice, it turned out, was in fact thin, “rotten” ice, Barber and his colleagues […]

  • 5 bob pohlhausen // Dec 14, 2009 at 1:29 pm

    What was in summer 2000, 01, 02 …. and earlier? What was the extend of “rotten ice” then? Any data published?

    Why a press release before the paper was published? Is the media reaction more important than science? Do you have a political message?

  • 6 GORE, Caught Lying really really badly... Desperately pathetic in fact. WAKE UP - Page 3 - // Dec 15, 2009 at 7:44 am

    […] although most of the ice seemed to have come back it was the WRONG KIND OF ICE. They called it

  • 7 fred holyman // Dec 26, 2009 at 9:55 am

    Barber’s story sounds as rotten as the rest of the tree ring circus gang

Leave a Comment