CM Archive
CM Archive Book Review line

Janet Perlman
Toronto, Kids Can Press, 1992. 32pp, cloth, $11.95
ISBN 1-55074-073-3. CIP.

Pre-school to Grade 2/Ages 3 to 7

Reviewed by Jane Robinson.

Volume 20 Number 6
1992 November

Animator/illustrator Janet Perlman's first picture-book is rooted in the familiar. It is based on her 1982 National Film Board children's film called The Tender Tail of Cinderella Penguin, still available on videocassette within a collection entitled Fables and Fantasy, Volume 1. It is easy to see why this entertaining 10-minute film won a number of awards, including the Parents' Choice Award for Best Children's Video and an Academy Award nomination. The story is told entirely through clever animation and beautifully expressive music, one a perfect complement to the other.

And although somewhat colloquialized, this book version, entitled more simply Cinderella Penguin, is still obviously recogniz­able as a retelling of the traditional fairy-tale. Of course, certain modifications are necessary, since all the characters are penguins (e.g., the glass flipper in place of the glass slipper)! Author Perlman's penchant for penguins explains her preoccupation, but what about the audience?

This book is probably not for traditional­ists. The penguins add a definitive humour and irreverence that appeal to young children. The expressiveness and detail within the illustrations retain the same lively quality that made the film version so enjoyable. The vibrance and clarity of the colours, achieved by using animation techniques in painting the illustrations, are what draw children to the book and sustain their attention. The text is secondary. Although it does not detract from the story, the narrative does not uphold any of the quirkiness of the characters or their predicaments.

For all the book's plusses, it does not tell as captivating a story as the film version, nor could I recommend the book as a fairy-tale retelling. But pre-school to grade 2 children will enjoy the silliness inherent in personify­ing penguins and seeing them brought to life with such vibrance.

Jane Robinson is a former teacher in Winnipeg, Manitoba.
line indexes


1971-1979 | 1980-1985 | 1986-1990 | 1991-1995


The materials in this archive are copyright © The Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission Copyright information for reviewers

Young Canada Works
Canada Works